Lowering Soil pH - Why Not Use Compost

Lowering soil pH by using compost is a safe effective way to manage many of the problems found with alkaline and desert soil. When I received this question from Liz in Arizona, I decided it was time to do a special page on how compost can lower soil pH. Here is Liz's question:

We live in South Eastern Arizona, in the desert. Our soil is alkaline (sandy). Will composting help the pH level?

We always add soil conditioner any time we plant. Because the water just runs right through, we water only the trees and large shrubs deeply. The others are watered very often.

I have hydrangea and other plants in pots, I am having trouble keeping the leaves in these pots from the yellow leaves with green veins, I feed these pot plants acid fertilizer one half strength on a regular basis, will compost help these pot plants too?

Lowering Soil pH and the Hydrangea

Compost is a great answer for lowering soil pH. It doesn't exactly lower soil pH, what it does is buffer the pH making the soil function as if it had a lower pH. Compost can effectively move your pH down a point without having any negative effect on the living soil community.

It's interesting that you are growing a hydrangea in one of your pots. Hydrangeas are a natural pH indicator. If you have blue hydrangeas you have acidic soil. If they are pink you have alkaline soil. Here are a couple of pictures showing a pink and a blue hydrangea.

Pink Hydrangea

In the this photo of the pink hydrangea if you look closely at the leaves you can see they are somewhat yellow with dark green veins. Yellow leaves with dark green veins are showing classic symptoms of iron deficiency or iron chlorosis. This is common with plants growing in alkaline soil as at high pH values iron tends to become insoluble and therefore not available to plants. We know the soil pH is alkaline as the flower is pink.

Blue Hydrangea

In this photo the plant has dark green leaves. The veins are even a little lighter in color. This plant is able to access enough iron as soil conditions are somewhat acidic. We know this because this hydrangea flower is blue.

Lowering Soil pH to Correct Iron Chlorosis

Yellow leaves with dark green veins is an indicator of an iron deficiency or iron chlorosis. Given that you have alkaline soil, your yellow leaves are likely caused by the soil pH rather than an actual deficiency of iron. In alkaline conditions the iron becomes insoluble so the plants can't access it.

Adding iron won't necessarily help, but if you want to try that make sure it is a chelated iron amendment. The chelated iron fertilizer has less chance of binding with other elements such as calcium and becoming unavailable to your plants.

For a total biological approach to lowering soil pH follow these two steps.

  1. Add compost. In your containers make your soil mix about a third compost. In other areas, if possible, amend your soil with 2-4 inches of compost every year. If you have earthworms you can just put the compost on top of the soil and the worms will dig it in for you.
  2. A couple of weeks after the compost has had a chance to work its magic add endo-mycorrhizal fungi spores to your hydrangea and any other pot plants showing symptoms of iron chlorosis. The fungi will establish better after the compost has had a chance of buffering or lowering the soil pH. These fungi use various enzymes to make iron and phosphorus available to plants in a form they can use.

The Ideal Soil Conditioner for Lowering Soil pH - Compost

Liz mentioned in her question that she uses soil conditioner every time she plants. It's important to use the right soil conditioner but you can not go wrong if you use compost. Here's why

  • Compost buffer soil pH thereby raising or lowering soil pH.
  • In the sandy desert soil it will improve water holding capacity by at least ten fold.
  • Makes a great habitat for the complex soil community that Nature has to manage your soil whatever its problems.

Check the pH of Your Irrigation Water

Liz mentioned that she was feeding her plants a half strength acid fertilizer. What I think might be happening is that the water is so alkaline the fertilizer is neutralized or possibly even made alkaline.

On the farm I used to have our river water, which was our irrigation supply, had a pH of close to 8. Check the pH of your water - it may be making that acid fertilizer alkaline.

Bottom Line for Lowering Soil pH

Use lots of compost as your soil conditioner. Look to soil biology, such as mycorrhizal fungi for the biggest part of your answer for both your regular soil and your containers.

Go to Soil pH page from Lowering Soil pH with Compost